I had issues with my previous Pickleball Shoes and wanted to get a new pair. I suffer from sciatica and thus support was important to me in addition to feeling a good fit. As it turned out my left foot was actually size 11.5 and my right 11 - so I decided on the tighter fit as I don't like sloppy shoes. Well after using them for some 30 games, I feel very comfortable in them, they grip enough and at the right time to allow me to move around the court. I appreciated the help I got in picking this particular pair of shoes. Would definitely recommend them to someone else even if one of them is a bit tight. I no longer notice the slightly tight left big toe any more.